Home | Contents | Search | Post | Issues| Solutions ]
Copyright (c) 12/2000 http://www.h1bvisasucks.com/ All Rights Reserved
LETTER FROM SENATOR LIEBERMAN TO THE MEMBERS OF USINPAC
Dear Friends:
The strength of the United States has always come from its diversity. Its diversity comes from its immigrant communities. We are a strong nation, a unified nation, because of our diversity.
One of our nation's most important and fastest growing immigrant communities is the Indian American Community. It is two million plus strong and growing. Approximately 10% of the medical students in this country are Indian American. One out of four high tech businesses in the San Francisco Bay Area is Indian American owned. The American landscape is full of Indian entrepreneurs who create economic growth and opportunity as small businessmen and -women. Indian Americans have the highest per capita income of any ethnic minority at $68,000. In short, Indian Americans are a success story.
It is time to translate that economic power into political clout. Indian Americans must be in the forefront of shaping domestic and international policy for the United States. They have earned a seat at the policy table, and the country will be better off for their participation in policy debates in Washington and beyond.
For instance, Indian Americans have unique insight into US-Indian relations. The community's desire to expand economic relations, particularly trade could be a win/win situation for both nations. The community's desire to bolster US-Indian strategic relations is also an important contribution, particularly as it relates to non-proliferation and anti-terrorism issues. It is also time to seriously consider increasing the permanent membership of the United Nations Security Council. As the world's largest democracy, India should be a priority candidate for a permanent seat.
But beyond international relations, we must look to improve things domestically for Indian Americans. Of course, we must fight any and all discrimination against Indian Americans wherever we may find it. But that is not enough. We must also actively create opportunities for Indian Americans to serve in high level positions in government. As President, I will see that this is the case.
I also oppose any efforts to eliminate or diminish the H1-B visa program. Why do we want to limit or otherwise handicap a community that has made such significant and important contributions to this country? It is counter-intuitive and counter-productive.
In closing, my Administration will be proactive in working with the Indian American community on international and domestic issues. I will make certain that Indian Americans have positions of responsibility in my Administration because it is good for our country, and it is the right thing to do.
Sincerely,
Joe Lieberman
http://www.usinpac.com/CanMsgToIndAme_jl_PE.asp
![]()
Letter from US Senator John
McCain on the H1b Issue Sept 28,2000
Thank
you for contacting
me regarding the high tech job market
in America and the H-1B visa program for highly skilled foreign workers. I
appreciated hearing from you.
In
1998, Congress passed legislation to raise the cap on visas for skilled foreign
workers in the face of an array of evidence demonstrating that Americans were
not filling the specialized jobs covered by the H1B visa category. At the
time, the Information Technology Association of America estimated that there
were more than 346,000 unfilled positions for highly skilled workers in American
companies. The Department of Labor estimated that the American economy would
generate 1.3 million new jobs each year for a decade in the computer and
information technology industries, but that American universities would be able
to supply only a quarter of the graduates needed to fill those jobs. The Hudson
Institute predicted that in a few years this worker shortage, if not addressed,
would cause a five percent drop in the growth rate of our economy a $200
billion annual
loss in national output.
The
American Competitiveness Act of 1998, which I cosponsored, raised the annual
cap on H‑1B visas for skilled
professionals from 65,000 in Fiscal Year 1998 to 115,000 in both FY 1999 and FY
2000, and to 107,500 in FY 2001. Nonetheless, even the higher number of
H‑1B admissions authorized by Congress for FY 1999 was reached only eight
months into that fiscal year, and the FY 2000 cap was reached in March 2000, or
only six months into the current fiscal year.
Congress
is currently considering legislation to further raise the annual cap on H-1B
visas. I support S. 2045, the main bill before the Senate on this issue, which
would add an additional 297,500 H-1B visas between FY2000 and FY 2002, as well as
expand the availability of math, science, and technology scholarships for
Americans. The 106' Congress is expected to take up this legislation before
adjourning in late 2000.
Further
raising the H-1B cap is a short term solution to the skilled‑worker
shortage in the United States, but over the long term, I believe we need to
address the underlying problem resulting in a shortage of skilled American
workers. Consequently, on October 27, 1999, I introduced S. 1804, the 21st
Century Technology Resources and Commercial Leadership Act, which addresses the
need to improve Americans' skills in math, science, engineering, and technology
in order to maintain our world leadership in high‑tech fields. Several
other bills before Congress would raise the H-1B visa cap, but focus less on the
long term goal of educating and training Americans to fill available high tech
jobs. S. 1804 would encourage innovation in improving elementary and secondary
education in math, science, and engineering, as well as provide powerful incentives
to retrain American workers who lack the skills to compete in the high tech
economy. In the interim, to provide for the requisite number of highly skilled
professionals until we have educated and trained a sufficient number of
Americans to fill these jobs, the bill would lift the cap on H-1B visas through
2006. All current information indicates that the supply of American
professionals in the math, science, engineering, and technology fields will not
meet the demand of American industries through at least that date.
Specifically,
S. 1804 provides for grants to be awarded under the supervision of the Secretary
of Commerce in consultation with the Office of Technology Policy and the
National Science Foundation, on a competitive basis, for implementing programs
that will improve the math, science, engineering, and technology skills of
American students and professionals. The types of programs to be awarded grants
are not specified so that Congress does not unintentionally foreclose new and
more innovative ideas from surfacing. The grants would be funded from
current H-1B visa application fees and could be awarded to companies, organizations,
schools, school districts, teachers, and institutions of higher
learning.
My
legislation would use H-1B visa fees to encourage innovation in our
schools, to teach American students the skills they will need to succeed in the
21st century economy, and in our companies, to train and retrain American
workers in the high‑tech skills American businesses rely upon. The
legislation would support corporate partnerships with schools or school
districts to improve math and science curricula; scholarships for students
willing to study advanced engineering or technology fields, and for those who
agree to teach math or science for a period of time after graduating
college; and innovative worker training and retraining programs within
American companies. It leaves open grant support for any proposal that promises
to improve the American talent pool in high‑tech fields.
Thank you again for contacting me about legislation to increase the pool of American talent in high‑technology fields. Please feel free to do so regarding any matter.
Sincerely,
John McCain
United States Senator
JM/dt
Note: See www.hudson.org This is an author of Workforce 2000 cited by US Senators like McCain as needing expanded H1b Visa Immigration See next like/item in www.h1bvisasucks.com http://www.ced.org/docs/report/report_immigration.pdf
Areas of Expertise
|
Note1: Mr. July is using foreign H1B Visa Labor in doing business with IBM
Note2: In a prior edition of ComputerWorld an IBM Manager Rod Adkins from Texas was cited as saying IBM has a shortage of IT Talent and that IBM Needs extensive H1B Labor to support their efforts.
Note3: In the next item showing the Workforce 2000 report Committee for Economic Development a senior Chairman is Raymond Gilmartin CEO of Merck. The company uses extensive H1B Visa labor. http://www.ced.org/docs/report/report_immigration.pdf
Analysis of Report on H1B Visa
McCain identified the technical professional shortage thru 2006. Let's compare this to the 1849 Goldrush. When this started people claimed the supply of Gold would last years this did not happen. Why not let the free market system in place deal with this issue. The American Economy works great here leave it alone the market forces will correct the problem. Bringing in the oversea technical professional when these chances are not even provided to the America workers will destroy our ability to compete not enhance it along with our trade imbalance. This will result in higher paying jobs which are the growth of the US Economy going elsewhere With respect to American IT Professionals being replaced this by foreign workers the number of cases I could sight to you would take a long time. This is already happening by 100,000+ per year now. This firms do not have powerful incentives to retrain since Congress is giving them the quick fix. Well look at Lucent to see how well this quick fix works! In the letter McCain states he supports increasing the H1B Immigration to about 300,000 per year thru 2006. Knowing this industry each of these jobs is around $100K per year. McCain as a benefit we get $700 per person on immigration fees which will be then used for education funds for American Students. This sounds great at first until you look at the numbers.
300,000 H1B Visas x 7 years = 2.1 Million People (plus families = about 4 million)
Wages Lost to Americans in the High Tech Industry.
Year 1: 300,000 x $100,000/Person = $30 Billion
Year2: (300,000 + 300,000) x 100K = $60 Billion
Year3: 900k x 100k = $90 Billion
Year4: 1.2 Mil x 100k = $120 Billion
Year5:1.5 Mil x 100k = $150 Billion
Year6: 1.8 Mil x 100k = $180 Billion
Year7: 2.1 Mill x 100k = $210 Billion
------------------------------
$740 Billion in Lost Income to American High Tech Workers
Education Fees: 2.1 Mil x $700 = $1.48 Billion
About 0.2% Investment towards education of American Tech Workers. With a loss of $738 Billion in On the Job Training lost to American Workers!!
In addition people in these types of jobs by homes. While many H1B Visa workers do not and export the funds overseas..
2.1 Mil Homes x $200K/Home = $420 Billion in Real Estate not bough in America
We could take this further but I hope you can see this H1B program in effect exports around Over One Trillion from the US Economy to support fast buck marketing by high tech job shop firms.
This is the deal small high tech business is getting. Disinvest in small high tech business at the Federal Level via Section 8A and Blanket Purchase order agreements. Import foreign labor to give big corporate interest the competitive edge in high tech. Disinvest in the American labor force because this is cheaper. Fail to train the American Labor force train our overseas competition so that they may be able to take away the high tech industry from the USA which the US economy is depending to create 50% of the jobs within several years. Look the other way at organized crimes involvement federal and commercial procurement of high tech services and they put up smoke screen that Campaign finance reform is a desired goal when McCain fails to see the real impact to the US economy since this will take several years to reap the rewards of his agenda.
Look Now: The training funds setup for the Americans displaced by H1-B Labor will not be available!!
Bush Plans To End Job Program, Use Funds To Process Foreign Workers
By JULIA MALONE / Cox Washington Bureau WASHINGTON -- The Bush administration is planning to cancel a high tech job
training program for Americans and use the funds to speed up processing for
foreign workers. The move is raising concern in some high tech companies, which pay fees of
$1,000 for each foreigner hired under the H-1B visa program designed for
temporary, high-skilled workers. The aim of the $185 million training program has been to build up skills in
the American workforce so that fewer foreign workers would be needed. In a little publicized item in the federal budget for next year, however, the
Bush administration said that the job training efforts "have not proven to
be effective." Beginning next fall, the plan calls for redirecting the
money to reduce the years' long backlog for certifying permanent foreign
workers. Assistant labor secretary Emily Stover DeRocco told the publication
Washington Technology last month, "We have no evidence that it was
replacing the need for foreign workers that employers were bringing in." Some in industry agree that the program has missed the mark, but they argue
that it should be reformed, not ended. "This kind of breaks the faith" with the companies paying the fees,
said Harris Miller, president of Information Technology Association of America,
a trade group of 500 high tech companies, who are the main employers of H-1B
workers. "The clear intent was for there to be a trade-off," Miller said.
"We in the business community would get to bring in more foreign workers,
but we also pay a special tax on that, and that tax is to help with the
fundamental problem that necessitates foreign workers in the first place." Miller and others say the training effort has failed because it provides
chiefly basic training for low-level jobs and therefore could not provide
skilled computer programmers that industry was seeking. "There have been
some problems with the training programs, but there have also been some
successes," Miller said. The Labor Department program as well as a smaller scholarship program run by
the National Science Foundation are now being studied by the General Accounting
Office, the investigative arm of Congress. Paula Collins, director of government relations for Dallas-based Texas
Instruments, Inc., said Monday that her company had been disappointed with
Labor's training program. Her company had hoped it would help finance a new Texas state effort to boost
the number of electrical engineers and computer science graduates. She said that
she found the federal assistance program was not designed for college degrees. Even so, Collins said she doubted that the Bush administration would be able
to cancel the training program any time soon. "An agreement was made"
with industry on the fees, she said. She added that the Bush budget proposal to close the program is "opening
up discussions" behind the scenes to change it. At the same time, a critic of hiring foreign workers in high technology
argued this week that the plan to eliminate the job training program has brought
new candor to the discussion of the foreign worker program. "At least the Bush administration recognizes this program to be the sham
that it was from the start," said Norman Matloff, a computer science
professor, at the University of California at Davis. He said the training "was a smokescreen from the beginning" so that
industry could hire more workers from overseas. Matloff holds that industry
could find enough American workers if it were willing to hire and retrain
programmers who are over age 40 and pay higher salaries. "What they really ought to do is can the whole H-1B program, or enforce
the spirit of the law," he said. The foreign worker program requires
payment of prevailing wage, he said, "but there are a ton of loopholes for
you to get around that."
04-09-02
![]()
http://www.davidicke.net/tellthetruth/reststory/bronfmanscrime.html